Bug #5509: No groups directory in /var/rudder/configuration-repository - Rudder - Issue Tracker

Actions

Copy link

Bug #5509

closed

No groups directory in /var/rudder/configuration-repository

Added by Matthieu C about 10 years ago. Updated about 10 years ago.

Status:

Released

Priority:

Assignee:

Nicolas CHARLES

Category:

Web - Config management

Target version:

2.6.19

Pull Request:

https://github.com/Normation/rudder/p...

Severity:

UX impact:

User visibility:

Effort required:

Priority:

Name check:

Fix check:

Regression:

Description

The groups directory is absent and there is a lot of pending changes not commited to git:

[root@rudderweb2 configuration-repository]# git status
# On branch master
# Changed but not updated:
#   (use "git add/rm <file>..." to update what will be committed)
#   (use "git checkout -- <file>..." to discard changes in working directory)
#
#       deleted:    groups/025cd57c-b706-4ef9-9deb-6dc8d785063d.xml
#       deleted:    groups/02802478-0f7e-4c0c-ade8-e4c8b2677ae1.xml
#       deleted:    groups/083356d0-f1ec-4d30-a158-18d3b4d3bc36.xml
#       deleted:    groups/0e509c9b-2f92-4037-bc63-2941a36e369e.xml
#       deleted:    groups/0f8bcc72-b920-4e5b-b7ff-791dcc328f34.xml
#       deleted:    groups/116f6392-846a-4c40-9d6b-beb3707bab92.xml
#       deleted:    groups/1fc98fc8-d3e1-4339-9176-d5ace6698949.xml
#       deleted:    groups/24c1f80b-4d21-4d22-b260-8b5148bef7c5.xml
#       deleted:    groups/26105c39-43c6-478a-a45a-dd2f81199593.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/0dd3fa48-a277-47a2-8e83-e4a9e7b18857.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/0e9ce67c-b009-433e-bf91-a439c9bc7874.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/3cd1d5e3-4794-4165-bde6-dbadea5d888c.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/438a04b1-820a-4433-a751-c4ed629e88bd.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/a236c20f-ceda-4241-81b2-337deb5f66d4.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/c7b7648e-8b4e-4043-a7c3-79bc542ba15e.xml
#       deleted:    groups/27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/dd4bc796-0942-44a6-b039-85e63e6b97e7.xml
#       deleted:    groups/2f3bbaad-972a-4c49-9549-bca6883d235d.xml
#       deleted:    groups/2fdca9cf-c653-4800-8292-9f4bcf1b8359.xml
#       deleted:    groups/375a4278-8c54-4c59-bd14-d3ce3b93ab87.xml
#       deleted:    groups/4aedcea4-2e5b-4767-85ea-384e06653cad.xml
#       deleted:    groups/4d5831ac-5224-45af-b286-c2937b3b9ed2.xml
#       deleted:    groups/556a2e35-6ab0-4d29-98fc-be4a525bc88a.xml
#       deleted:    groups/56119a55-e830-46ae-b6b0-5b84c774b12e.xml
#       deleted:    groups/63d46937-1fc3-40bd-9294-72912c2c98df.xml
#       deleted:    groups/66ffde7b-5dbd-4235-b486-b32b2900f930/category.xml
#       deleted:    groups/69849ce4-b819-44a1-a115-716de121197e.xml
#       deleted:    groups/6c948728-b73e-4e22-b207-04d35cf62e9d.xml
#       deleted:    groups/6ffd8b64-dcba-48ad-9abb-3083f5adc737.xml
#       deleted:    groups/7792b2fc-06ee-4554-94da-4d81a7985592.xml
#       deleted:    groups/80c33c54-7d49-4017-b0cb-a0c7b40236e8.xml
#       deleted:    groups/93320741-8ee9-44ad-b9cc-8f1cea063d90.xml
#       deleted:    groups/958a467b-f172-4e17-9f32-6498775a807b.xml
#       deleted:    groups/9638efff-c09a-484b-9ba2-80115048ca64.xml
#       deleted:    groups/9cd22b29-bce9-4aaf-9046-689834959299.xml
#       deleted:    groups/a7faf3b8-06b7-45f1-afc0-21e2db2fa6b4.xml
#       deleted:    groups/a8abde18-38fa-4518-a5ee-80f3d02e0a3f.xml
#       deleted:    groups/aca7a06e-dc8e-47d8-a5e2-349720c1b974.xml
#       deleted:    groups/ad6548c9-35f5-4815-8e41-640189de4499.xml
#       deleted:    groups/bb2a7f53-d462-440d-86f6-44862d8065f5.xml
#       deleted:    groups/bcd7d7e6-30f8-44de-a790-0ced036e7741.xml
#       deleted:    groups/be5b62fb-5d46-43e5-b465-2c14b955b1fd.xml
#       deleted:    groups/c1810ccf-73dc-49b1-8191-b99845297f90.xml
#       deleted:    groups/category.xml
#       deleted:    groups/d7db7758-e1e2-40f8-8354-97b6724a6cff.xml
#       deleted:    groups/ddcba2a9-7796-4822-8eae-77b900b67b45.xml
#       deleted:    groups/df8ac383-94fc-4fe2-b5bf-3f2d1ffdb47e.xml
#       deleted:    groups/e115d71d-acb0-4cc8-aced-9da59dbb99db.xml
#       deleted:    groups/e36da5f4-fcdf-4061-a63e-456e3f77bf91.xml
#       deleted:    groups/e561ce25-5dfb-4da6-9664-a5df97483f43.xml
#       deleted:    groups/e66f3fcb-60df-4a7d-84f0-0741aa1c74df.xml
#       deleted:    groups/eef0999b-e612-46b3-9cb1-fe2cc85b92eb.xml
#       deleted:    groups/faa50dcc-331c-4d36-9060-954b4ded5acb.xml
#       deleted:    groups/fab8e88c-c751-428e-ba42-bd3ea6a28b50.xml
#
no changes added to commit (use "git add" and/or "git commit -a")

After commiting the changes and creating a new group, I have:

[root@rudderweb2 configuration-repository]# tree groups/
groups/
`-- 27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780
    `-- 5d2bd217-1504-4d87-a6a2-cf78f72a49a2.xml

1 directory, 1 file

The category corresponding to 27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780 has 8 groups inside, only one appears in the repository (and I think the category.xml is missing)

Related issues 1 (0 open — 1 closed)

Actions

Copy link

Updated by François ARMAND about 10 years ago

Category set to Web - Config management
Assignee set to François ARMAND

Thanks for the information.

I think it's the expected behaviour, and the problem is more likelly that the groups should not have been in "deleted" state.
Normally, a "full archive" (in tab utilities > archives) should clean up everything and set a neat state back.

I will try to understand the root issue, though.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Matthieu C about 10 years ago

Here's the step I did to reproduce the problem:

Utilities -> Archive -> Archive groups
the directory groups/ seems to be good

Delete a group in a category in Nodes management -> Groups
the entire category seems to have been deleted from groups/ directory, nothing gets committed

[root@rudderweb2 groups]# git status
# On branch master
# Changed but not updated:
#   (use "git add/rm <file>..." to update what will be committed)
#   (use "git checkout -- <file>..." to discard changes in working directory)
#
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/0dd3fa48-a277-47a2-8e83-e4a9e7b18857.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/0e9ce67c-b009-433e-bf91-a439c9bc7874.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/3cd1d5e3-4794-4165-bde6-dbadea5d888c.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/438a04b1-820a-4433-a751-c4ed629e88bd.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/a236c20f-ceda-4241-81b2-337deb5f66d4.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/c7b7648e-8b4e-4043-a7c3-79bc542ba15e.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/category.xml
#       deleted:    27bb5090-647b-4d2f-8797-c403579f1780/dd4bc796-0942-44a6-b039-85e63e6b97e7.xml
#
no changes added to commit (use "git add" and/or "git commit -a")

Actions

Copy link

Updated by François ARMAND about 10 years ago

Priority changed from N/A to 3

Could you please tell me the Rudder version used ?
When trying with 2.11.2, I get a sligtly different behaviour in wich only the category is deleted, and the commit is missing (not all other groups are deleted).

Note that if the category is modified and saved, the git status come back to a clean state.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Matthieu C about 10 years ago

rpm -qa|grep -i rudder
rudder-techniques-2.11.2.release-1.EL.6.noarch
rudder-jetty-2.11.2.release-1.EL.6.noarch
rudder-webapp-2.11.2.release-1.EL.6.noarch
rudder-agent-2.11.2.release-1.EL.6.x86_64

Actions

Copy link

Updated by François ARMAND about 10 years ago

Thanks for the information.

That bug seems important for you, could you please details what are the bad things it makes happen (appart from the git status result)? Did you see other effects on Rudder behaviour? That would help qualify the problem.

Actions

Copy link